Blue Sky Bakery
“I tried the pumpkin apple walnut muffin and a few other muffins and I loved all of them.”
“They make the most scrumptious muffins and chocolate chip banana bread known to man!”
“I've tried the pumpkin-banana-walnut , the blueberry-peach-apple and the plain pumpkin muffins and they are all delightful.”
Blue Sky Bakery
Take-out: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Inexpensive
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
The few times a year that I visit Brooklyn, my friends and I stop by this place. The muffins are fresh, delicious, and hearty. I love the fruit flavored ones. Which fruit ones? Every fruit flavored one!
Maybe random but when I had a dog, I used to buy her little doggie treats that were next to the register. I think my dog liked them a lot.
Oh man, these muffins were SO good. I got the zucchini, chocolate, berry one. It was just the right amount of moist from the zuke, but not to the point where it was soggy. The top of the muffin had just the right amount of crisp to it, and it overall, had an amazing texture. They're also really generous with the mix-ins. There wasn't a bit that didn't have berry or chocolate in it.
I finally got around to trying Blue Sky Bakery's famous bran muffin! It was good, but somehow, not great 🙁 The crumb was decent, but it really needed some butter because the two muffins I tried were both dry. Where's the butter?! I guess my expectations were higher than what was delivered and i probably would get another one if I was in the neighborhood, but I wouldn't go out of my way for these muffins.
The pineapple muffin had filling inside! It was so crusty on the outside, and soft and flavorful within. Who knew muffin can kick ass?
Best muffins ever. We tried the Pumpkin Apple Walnut, the blueberry, and had some chocolate chip banana bread on the side. All three were delicious. The muffins stood out though as just ridiculously good. Just perfectly done – can't think of how muffins could get any better.
Visited Brooklyn over the weekend, had a great time hanging with friends, shopping, having a few drinks and whatnot, but in spite of all of this, the best part of the weekend may still be the muffins. I visited Blue Sky Saturday, Sunday AND Monday (before leaving) and am still missing their warm muffins..
Carrot/strawberry/cream cheese and banana/bran/apple/walnut.. warm, crunchy on the outside, warm and full of fillings. Stupid, foolish good. The iced coffee is also amazing. Such a great little shop, would make a point to come back next time I am in Brooklyn!
I had high hopes for the Blue Sky Bakery. High like the blue sky above Brooklyn. But not on a cloudy day. Because then you can't see it, and the comparison becomes dumb.
I finally went in here after missing their closing time 2-3 times on earlier food tours. I got a Blueberry Muffin because they remembered it. It was probably a 4-star muffin (i.e. very average, since I rate family owned places 3, 4 or 5 only), but because of all the hype and the fact that I was expecting the muffin from heaven to change my life forever, I'll keep it as a three. It was just a very average muffin that did nothing for me. In fact I may like the ones at Wegmans up in Buffalo better. Damn. That's cold.
And if you sleep with a member of the Blue Man Group or Rebecca Romijn from X-Men, then you might hear a "Blue Sigh." If you're any good.
Delicious! My only strike against them is they still don't take cards… Sometimes you need a muffin fix and have forgotten to get cash out!