Gotham Pizza
“However the cornmeal on the crust is a little odd at first, but adds a nice crunch to the pizza.”
“Ive only gotten delivery, but I probs should go and try when its fresh out the oven!!!”
“The margherita pizza is a must – little expensive for the full pie, but quality pizza in the Upper East.”
Gotham Pizza
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Under $10
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
delicious. my friend and i scarfed it down as soon as we got it. We ordered meatball pizza and cheese, and we really enjoyed it. It took a while to arrive but it was the perfect size to have before we went out. We split a large pie and a 12 inch pie among three people but probably could have had 2 large pies. We were incredibly hungry haha.
The crust is that perfectly done crispy but not overdone New York City pizza crust. If you don't go for just the plain cheese (which is great), try the grandma slice for sure. It's fantastic!
Still a few stars for the food but delivery the past three times takes OVER an hour for slices. I still order but plan ahead.
I can't speak for the actual store front but they provide me with food so quickly when I'm not willing to wear layers or really clothing and I'm being a bum. The delivery is super speedy to my area despite a seamless account that tells me 45 minutes. I almost have to throw on something decent enough to meet the delivery guy with the steaming hot, slightly greasy pizza they make. The crust is relatively thin and crunchy and they don't skimp on toppings or sauce.
I haven't ordered anything too fancy or complicated (pepperoni) from them but for a mere $20 you can feed two people relatively well and be in a lovely post-pizza food coma.
A classic pizzeria in a neighborhood that doesn't have a ton without walking for a few blocks! The service is really fast and they do a good job of keeping fresh pizzas coming out of the oven. They have a pretty wide variety of pizzas, with decent pricing for slices and fountain sodas. Everything is pretty standard for a pizzeria – plastic forks and knives, as well as wax cups with lids, etc.
Their white pizza is not one I would recommend – it doesn't have a ton of flavor unless you add garlic powder or something like that on top! Other than that, the other kinds I have tried are all fine!
The garlic knots are definitely worth a shot! Super cheap at like 4 or 5 for a dollar and they come out nice and warm.
They do have a lunch special which is something like 2 plain slices with one drink for $5, but I'm not sure if this is just during the week or not.
This place fills up with a lot of kids from nearby schools during the week at around lunch time, so keep that in mind depending on what time you're coming in! If you have somewhere to take it to go, do that! There isn't a lot of seating, and the kids sometimes stay well past when they're done eating.
Gotham added a delicious chicken pie to their pizza selection, and they also have w mozzarella / ricotta slice I never noticed before. More options, always better.
***
Clean location, fast friendly service, always freshly made pizza that's very good.
Their grandma's (margarita type) pizza is my fave, and while not my personal fave / preference, the grainy crispy thin crusted regular slices are a big hit with adults and kids – very good.
A handful of tables where you can sit and they also deliver.
I'm not a huge pizza person but I gotta say this place got super yummy pizza!! Thin crispy crunchy crust and bottom. And cheesy, not salty!!
I went twice already.
Friendly service and pizza is always fresh out of the oven.
If you love crispy crunchy cheesy pizza, I urge you to go get pizza from here on your NYC visit.
Plus can't beat $5 two slices and a soda.
Came to this place for lunch. They have a two slice and one drink special for $5 or $6. Got a regular slice and a margherita slice. I love the dough they use in this place.. It has a grainy texture to it. Would love to give this place more stars but I didn't think the pizza had a lot of taste.