Maggie Reillys Restaurant
“Stopped into Maggie's for a quick drink before a show and ended up staying for three!”
“Iris was great, the food was good (onion soup and the penne carbonara) and the locals made it especially interesting.”
“They even accommodated my friend that doesn't eat bacon by making some potato skins without the meat.”
Maggie Reillys Restaurant
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Happy Hour: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Price range.
$$ Price range $11-30
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
If you're hungry in the improv district of HellSea (deep West Chelsea), the options for booze and grub are thin. Maggie Reilly's is within a stone's throw of Reckless and other outposts, and a good choice for burgers, sandwiches, and pints. Don't expect endless lists of beers, but you'll be satisfied.
3.5 but bumping to a 4 for proximity and friendly service.
Had a great experience here. Was a quick pit stop before our journey. Our bartender Toni was so sweet. We enjoyed her stories as she strolled down memory lane and filled us in on how the city has evolved. It was really eariler so we where the only patrons at that time which was even better. The place isn't really big, definitely on the divey side, about 12 stools alongside the bar and there where like 6 tables towards the back. Fyi $20 minimum for card transactions. If in the area seems like a good spot to grab a drink before you embark onto your mission.
Let's call a spade a spade – this is a divey sports bar. And sometimes, that's exactly what you need. Decent beer selection, and they have food though I didn't order any.
This place is awesome if you just so happen to be in midtown and you're still in the mood for a beer or cocktail long after the party has ended. That's right you can a drink at this bar for cheap 24/7! It doesn't get better than that!! The ambience is a rustic Irish theme. When you arrive you will be greeted with a warm hello by the bartender Tonyann! Even the guest that were at the bar were just as friendly. She definitely sets the tone. She told me and my fiancé about her life and it made us feel close to her in the little bit of time that we spent there. I wasn't a fan of red wine. I ordered a Pinot noir that tastes very watery. I would suggest sticking to a cold beer or getting a mix drink.
This place is exactly what you need when you want a cheap beer and good conversation with friends. They also offer a pitcher for around $15. And for that I'll tip my hat to Ms. Maggie Reilly.
~depressing 90s/early 2000s alt. music and cheap beer~
This place was so cozy on a cold afternoon. There is a nice clean bar and a few tables in the back. The bartender/waitress were super nice and accommodating (loved their accents). They didn't seem annoyed that my husband and I were lugging around our travel bags.
We ordered the cheeseburger. It was juicy, delicious and came with some thick crispy bacon which made it extra yummy. I opted for the salad as a side which was fresh.
We also had some beers- a lagunitas ipa and a sam adams october fest for $6 each. Decently priced but it's unfortunate we were too early for happy hour.
Great spot over on 9th avenue. They have good happy hour deals and a nice selection of bar/pub food.
Try their Maggie lager it is really, really good beer. They also have seasonal ales, including Shocktop Pumpkin!
We were indecisive about what apps to order and the waiter suggested the platter which was a good selection of food (wings, potato skins, fries, onion rings and chicken tenders). They even accommodated my friend that doesn't eat bacon by making some potato skins without the meat.
I know shocking because who doesn't eat/love bacon! Anyhow, the platter was a great choice and a good amount of food for three of us.
We all liked this bar and the staff was friendly and attentive. Only downside is they have a $20 card minimum. Not sure if this is noted on their menu.